Subtext: What It Is and How to Use It to Add Depth to Your Writing

If you read a few articles on subtext, you’ll see the same definitions given: It’s writing “between the lines” and “beneath the surface” and “beyond the text” and other prepositional phrases that still leave you wondering, What on earth is this?
Subtext is so hard to define because it’s all about giving over meaning without defining it. It adds to the story without any words actually being added. But subtext is all around us, and it shows up in the best of storytelling as well. This is a higher-level writing skill, but once you practice incorporating it into your scenes, it will add depth and meaning to your storytelling.

So What Is Subtext?
Let’s get this clear. There is the text, the face-value words on the page: I ask you how you are, and you say, “Great!” Simple, straight, and factual, nothing deeper going on.
Then there is subtext. It is the layer that adds additional meaning to the words on the page: I ask you how you are, and you snap back, “How do you think I’m doing?”
Huh? What was that about? That was subtext—something is happening beneath the surface. Anytime dialogue, description, or action seem to imply something deeper, there is subtext going on.
Why Is Subtext Important?
If you’re writing a story about the importance of family, you don’t want every character to go around saying, “Family is the best! I could never have gotten through that without my siblings!” That is what we call “beating the reader over the head” with your theme. It drains any power out of the message you were hoping to give and turns it into something readers roll their eyes at.
But with subtext, that implicit meaning can show up without a character saying a word. You can write an entire story about tyranny and how power corrupts, and yet on the surface all we see are animals on a farm fighting each other. Subtext allows for depth and meaning without hitting the reader over the head with it.
There’s a second reason subtext is so crucial: When we’re children, we pretty much say what we mean. A child will yell, “I’m hungry!” but an adult will say, “When’s dinner?” As we grow older, we learn to cover up and speak around what we really mean. This is partially out of social politeness (we can’t really tell the airplane mate how bad they smell) and partially to hide our vulnerabilities. Saying how we really feel opens us to rejection and ridicule and judgment. So we usually just don’t.

To our friend, we might jokingly say, “Gosh, what would I do without you?” instead of looking them in the eye and saying, “I really appreciate that you helped me. It means a lot.” To our boss, we might say, “Oh, yes, I can take care of that!” and then start crying when they walk away because now we won’t be home till midnight. Each of those examples contains subtext. It captures how we realistically express ourselves.
Subtext is also found in the subconscious realm. The majority of our decisions stem from the subconscious; we are motivated by, and make decisions based upon, our subconscious beliefs. If a character has a belief that they will always fail, they won’t bother to sign up for the interview. If they believe they don’t have the right to take up space, they will hunch over and rarely speak at a meeting. If they believe no one loves them, they will be unable to accept love from another character. And they won’t even know that it’s happening or why.
And here’s what’s really cool (please nerd out with me on this): A character’s inner wound, or the flaw they must overcome, is very often a subconscious belief. They’re likely not even aware of it, which is why the events of the story unfold to help them learn their lesson.
So in essence, we need subtext because we carry worlds beneath our conscious world, and the best way to show this to readers is with a writing technique that implies those layers without fully uncovering them.
Where Subtext Shows Up
The Macro Level
Subtext on a macro level reveals what the story is really about. What message is the author imparting? What are they saying about this topic? If you can’t answer that about your book, go read my blog post on “How to Write a Character Arc That Actually Works.” It’ll help you with what we’re about to discuss.
Every main character has an inner wound, a goal, and a need, right? Right. A girl may have the goal of winning the national spelling bee. That’s an external goal. Why does she want that? Here’s where subtext comes in—because her parents are immigrants and she feels the need to prove their right to be there. She wants to prove that they all fit in. Will she ever admit this aloud? No. It lies in the subtext of the story.
And what about her inner wound? In this case, it’s likely a subconscious belief that she will never belong in this strange place. Her way of trying to fix the problem is to win an English-language contest. But what does she neeeed? Let me hear you say it: Yes! What she needs is a community and/or friend group who make her and her family feel welcome and at home—even if she doesn’t win. She needs to realize she already belongs.
This intrinsically connects human psychology and storytelling, which I find fascinating. This girl’s subconscious motivation will be the engine behind her actions. It will surface at critical plot points and be the reason behind many choices she makes. This “subtext-objective,” as Linda Seger calls it in her book Writing Subtext, is the underlying driving force of the story. The stronger it is, the more room for conflict and subtext, and thus the more depth and narrative direction
Subtext on the macro level will also be embedded in the theme(s) of the book, which are played out through the plot. In the above example, if there’s a theme of home or belonging, then very likely there will be a B Character who struggles with home, or is maybe an outcast in some other way. Other characters and plot points will weave in the theme, and it will all lead to an underlying subtext.

The Micro Level
On a scene, paragraph, and line level, subtext will show up in the descriptions and dialogue. I once had a writing instructor (Carter No-Clue-His-Last-Name) who said, “Subtext is what the moment is about rather than what happens in the moment.” It’s about the meaning of what’s going on rather than the actual actions. So that’s a good guiding question to ask yourself: What do I want this moment to mean, and how do I use subtext to achieve that?
Subtext shows up in conscious character choices, like when a woman on a date orders the cheapest item on the menu because she’s about to break up with the guy and feels guilty. And like we mentioned, subtext often shows up in the subconscious choices, like when we keep checking our pocket for our phone to make sure it’s there—without realizing it.
What’s important to keep in mind is that it’s much easier to add in this subtext after you have a draft and you’re going back in to revise. It’s A-OK to write “I hate you!” in a piece of dialogue just to reach the end of the scene. Revision is the time to build in the subtext.
How to Bring Subtext into Your Writing
Like with editing, we need to start from the big, foundational elements and work our way down to the small stuff. You first need to identify what your story is about (on a thematic level) and what your characters’ subtext-objectives are. Once you know what is driving your characters on a subconscious and conscious level, you can then work that in, scene by scene, into the description, action, and dialogue.
The difficulty here is in conveying that meaning without actually writing it out. I recently edited a novel where the character admitted in dialogue, “I do X as a coping strategy so I don’t have to think about how hard life is.” While understandable, in saying that straight out you’ve just made the subtext the text.
Is there a time and place for that conversion to happen? Yes, perhaps at the very end of a character’s arc. But it needs to be handled delicately because it’s rare for a person to become conscious of such a belief and to then share it with someone else.
Writers may not even realize the subtext they’re layering into their first draft. This can happen especially when the topic is close to their heart, or stemming from a personal bias (or anytime there’s a subconscious belief involved!). But at the end of the day, subtext is a tool you can grip to carve meaning into your story.
Here are some practical ways you can work subtext into your scenes:
In Dialogue
This is one of the most likely places for subtext to appear, for the reasons we gave above. Any time emotions are involved, people will use subtext to disguise their true thoughts and feelings. Try to use techniques like…
The Pause:
A friend asks, “Wanna go to the mall with me?” and after a long pause the other friend says, “I’d love to come.”
Hmm. Do they really?
The Conversation Changer: This reveals avoidance or discomfort. (Extra points if the conversation they switch to reveals further subtext.)
The husband asks, “Can we talk about what happened the other day?” and the wife says, “Ugh, do you see what’s happening to my flowers? They’ll die any day now.”
Contrast Between Dialogue and an Action Beat:
“I never lied to you,” he said, crossing his fingers behind his back.
Saying One Thing but Meaning Something Else:
He said, “There’s a fantastic Indian place on Fourth Street. Maybe we should try it sometime.”
She gave him a thin-lipped smile. “Oh, I’m not a fan of Indian cuisine.”
It is likely something else that she’s not a fan of.
In Actions and Description
When it comes to actions, what characters do or don’t do reveals subtext. If a father hangs up his kids’ report cards, but only when they contain all A’s, that says a lot about his parenting and the expectations in the home. If two brothers take opposite sides at the table to hear their father’s will, that will imply something different than if they sit side by side.

Subtext can also be revealed in how things are described. For example, say a baron gives a necklace to his much younger betrothed, and to her, the gem looks like a mouth swallowing her whole. That’s a strong implication of what she thinks of her upcoming marriage. A person who nearly drowned may describe a rippling lake as a snake waiting to swallow its prey. That connects with the subconscious—our past and experiences will inform how we view things. (I discuss this some more in “How to Use Setting to Convey Emotion.”)
You can also bring in subtext by using words that evoke associations or are laden with meaning. For example, a man might describe war as “crushing,” and later it’s revealed his best friend was crushed beneath a tank. A foster child might refer to her foster home as “The Prison” since that’s how it feels to her.
Subtext also shows up in repetition, whether through words or images. In Parked by Danielle Svetcov, Jeanne Anne and her mother are homeless, yet the word that passes between them the most is “Okay.” We’re okay, it’s okay, okay—all reinforcing the idea that they are so far from okay.
Writers have the ability to choose which words and description will best evoke emotion. Go one step further, and those words will create a subtext that adds layers of depth to a story.
In Conclusion
Subtext makes readers ask questions and hunt for their own answers, which makes them more invested in the story. This is exactly what we want.
As you revise your scenes, look at what your characters are saying, doing, and thinking, and check what else might be going on beneath the surface. What are they feeling but not expressing? What beliefs or fears are influencing their choices? Look for ways to let their actions, reactions, dialogue, and even the way they describe their surroundings hint toward their inner world.
If you get stuck creating that subtext, just come back to this question: How can I make this mean more than what it says? That will lead to subtext.
FAQs on Subtext
In one line, what is subtext?
Subtext is the meaning, emotion, or intention that comes through in a story without being stated outright.
How do I know if my story has subtext?
Look at what your characters say and do, then consider what readers might infer from their choices, reactions, and omissions. Are there feelings, beliefs, tensions, or intentions that come through without being stated outright?
How do I add subtext to my writing?
Start with what your characters want, what they’re feeling, and what they might be trying to hide. Then look for ways those things can come through in their dialogue, actions, descriptions, and decisions.
Can subtext be too subtle?
Yes. Readers need enough clues to make connections and understand what’s happening beneath the surface. If they have no way to interpret a moment, they may miss the meaning entirely. This is not to say that readers will understand all the subtext right away—it can take the entire book for them to understand the message of the story or another read or two to fully understand what was going on—but there should be enough clues for readers to pick up on scene-level subtext.
Does every scene need subtext?
There can be more straightforward scenes that need less depth. But if a scene involves tension, conflict, relationships, or character development, subtext is usually helpful in adding layers.
What’s the difference between “show, don’t tell” and subtext?
The goal of “show, don’t tell” is to immerse the reader in the scene. At a family dinner, you’ll describe the smell of the dishes, the clink of glasses, the chatter.
The goal of subtext is to convey deeper meaning or intention. At that same family dinner, certain details will emerge: who the mother is not sitting next to and which topics are being avoided.
In the words of a writing instructor I had, “Subtext is neither showing nor telling, because subtext is everything that you don’t mention.”
About Adina
Adina Edelman is a book editor who works with authors of memoir and fiction, especially historical, mystery, sci-fi/fantasy, literary, and middle-grade fiction. She’s all about mining your message, unearthing the gold in your story—not just the grammar errors.
Adina has worked on over 140 titles in the past six years (and published one of her own). She offers 30-minute coaching sessions alongside her editing services.
Find out more About Me
Connect: LinkedIn
Learn about Editing Services


Comments